- This is in answer to:
- Do you believe in the death penalty? Defend your answer. See all answers
-
- July 26, 2010 by FullGrownChild
- My Thoughts on the Death Penalty
-
This is gonna be a lil long winded at times but I tried to keep it as short as i could by not going into detail about every point i bring up otherwise this would have been a novel. lol any way enjoy and comment if u like
Do you believe in the death penalty? Defend your answer.
wow, thats a hard 1 to answer. i really dont feel like this is one of those things that you can take sides on. you have to put yourself in a few different situations (hypothetical situations)
ok so im sure im not alone when i linked the death penalty with murder crimes and started thinking along the lines of "take a life and have your life taken". so then I started wondering, is murder the only thing you can get the death penalty for? so...... i googled it. (i wonder how i found info b4 google? oh well)
any way so the 1st thing i googled was "Death penalty" that sent me to Wikipedia and it gave a definition :
"Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is the execution of a person by judicial process as a punishment for an offense. Crimes that can result in a death penalty are known as capital crimes or capital offenses."
it didnt just say murder it said capital crimes or capital offenses. so next google search was to find a list to help me get an idea on what capital crimes are. i came across a link to www.criminal-law-lawyer-source.com. where i got this :
"A capital offense is a felony crime that is considered so serious that it is punishable by death. Death for a capital offense is called capital punishment. Currently, thirty-eight states have laws, which make a criminal offense punishable by death."
"First-degree murder is considered a capital offense in all states, which allow capital punishment. Many states provide that a capital offense is murder with a certain number of aggravating factors.
Aggravating Factors
Aggravating factors can include, but are not limited to:
* Robbery
* Kidnapping
* Assault
* Multiple or repeat murder
* Murder of a public officer
* Crimes against minors
Capital offense crimes in some states also include aircraft hijacking, train wrecking, treason, drug trafficking, sexual assault, rape of a minor, and terrorism. "
so lets look at this, robbery? i didnt know that. i started out saying that you have to put yourself in these hypothetical situations so i'm going to do that. 1) i rob a person for what ever reason, should i go to jail? yes be "executed" ? dont think so
2) say i'm the 1 being robbed, i still feel the same way. yes jail but not the death penalty.
kidnapping....that 1 i didnt know about.
1) i dont have any children but lets say i did. would i want the person who kidnapped my child to die? hmmmm, at 1st yes i would probably feel that way especially if he harmed my child in any way. but then i started thinking that would be way to easy. in this situation i feel like the person should be in jail 4 ever.
2) now lets say im the kidnapper. still the same. just jail time
Assault? what kind of assault? verbal, physical, sexual? well i guess im gonna have too look at all of them.
verbal- i yell at u i die? no i yell at u i go to jail? no same thing if you do it to me
physical-we get into a fight.....jail time? maybe depending on how bad the fight is. death? mmmm no
but if im some where and i get attacked and beaten almost to death. yes for jail and i think i might be ok with the death penalty.
or if i come attack you and you almost die. should i die because of what i did? my natural instinct to want to stay alive will be screaming no but at the same time that would probably be the right thing because i shouldnt have attacked you like that so i dunno im kinda on the fence with that one.
sexual-would i want my rapist to die...wow. im really not sure how i feal about that one b/c there are sooooooooo many different things going through my head if i went into detail about all of them i'd be here all day. things like do i know my attacker, did they beat me, did i get pregnant...things like that so im not sure how to answer that 1. if i were the attacker? well being a woman im not sure how thats possible exactly. im not saying that a woman has never rapped a man all im saying is i dont know how you would go about making that happen. especially if the attacker is me, im not very hard to fight off.... a gallon of milk gets heavy to me after holding it for 2+ minutes...yea im that weak.
i'm going to move to crimes against minors next b/c i want to save the murder thing for last b/c i can tell its going to pull me in another direction.
ok so crimes against minors? minor being what? some 1 younger than 18?ok lets go with that. i steal an ipod from my lil sister's friend (she's 16) should i die? no. this situation doesnt work in reverse b/c of the term "against minors" i'm 23 soooooooooo....... yea.
ok so now murder. lets start with Multiple or repeat murder and Murder of a public officer. so what your telling me is if i only kill 1 person and that person is not a public officer than its ok? thats all im really gonna say about this 1 b/c if not i could go on and on about why i killed this person and was i drunk or do i wanna play "the crazy card" and blah blah blah.
so what is murder exactly? a person taking someone else's life? is it that simple? if it were that simple wouldnt the person administering the death penalty be a murderer? if a woman has an abortion is that murder? some say its only murder if the woman is however far along, some say its a life at conception. but either way is that murder? i dont know. should a woman get the death penalty for having an abortion? should i be killed if i did that? should u? should anyone? who's to say?

It's my understanding (without google!) that a crime against a minor would be things like sexual abuse, pedophile behaviors, abusing your position or authority in their lives such as being a dad and putting your 12 yr old out for prostitution so you can buy drugs. Also things like having drugs around the kids (meth lab in the home) and taking them along when you do drug deals, yadda yadda.
It's hard to define something that is such an ambiguous statement, but I do believe it is ambiguous on purpose. In an ideal world, we'd like to think common sense enters the picture. I seriously doubt it does any longer. It's more a tit-for-tat between attorneys on who can pull a phrase from a law and twist it around to make it work for their client. It's more of a game, it seems, than justice.
Justice. Now there's an interesting concept!